More or Less Planning?


When I ask project management students to list actions that are key to successful projects, the overwhelming majority of things on the list are related to planning.

We actually spend most of the time and energy in execution and control rather than planning. So, what’s going on? I think the students’ lists reflect frustrations – struggling to change and cope with plans that do not accurately incorporate reality. Their perception is that much of the struggle could be diminished through better planning.

At the same time, I’ve seen many organizations where there is a strong bias for quick action versus comprehensive planning. Those organizations reward managers that are “quick on their feet” and good “firefighters” (when was the last time any of us were recognized for good planning?).

Are the students just a bit naive? Maybe not. I’ve had European colleagues voice similar views about our planning: something along the lines of, “How did you cowboys ever get to the moon?”

Certainly, the more time we spend on planning, we delay getting to work. And, just as certainly, the less the plan reflects the realities, the more we have to deal with discrepancies, variances, and change. How do you determine the balance? Or, is that a false choice?

I’ve been persuaded that we need to plan, but do it slightly differently than in our “traditional” project paradigm. In a later blog, I’ll talk about some of the processes coming to be known as adaptive or agile methods. But, in the meantime, what do you do?


1 thought on “More or Less Planning?”

  1. User Avatar

    In Feb. 2007 the PM Network magazine had a terrific article on what they called “alpha project managers” – those who make an additional 85 percent more than the average project manager and are held in high esteem by their colleagues. According to their info, alphas spend TWICE as much time on planning as their non-alpha peers even though both groups rank it roughly the same in importance. Ah, well, knowing is not doing . . . and here’s another example of that in action!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top